How to Mix and Match James Hardie Siding Profiles and Colors

Table of Contents

Siding does more than protect your home—it plays a major role in how your home looks from the street. One of the most effective ways to improve curb appeal is to mix and match James Hardie siding profiles and colors. At Hawthorn Home Exteriors, we help homeowners explore different combinations through high-resolution renderings, so you can see exactly how each design will look before installation begins.

Why Mix and Match James Hardie Siding?

Many homeowners ask if they can mix different James Hardie siding styles and colors—and the answer is absolutely! In fact, we encourage it. By combining different profiles, you can create a custom, visually appealing exterior that highlights architectural details and enhances curb appeal.

Benefits of Mixing and Matching Siding

  1. Enhanced Curb Appeal: Different siding styles add depth and dimension to your home.
  2. Customization: Tailor your home’s exterior to reflect your personal style.
  3. Cost-Effective Options: Using different materials strategically can help balance costs.
  4. Increased Home Value: A well-designed exterior can boost your home’s resale value.
  5. Highlighting Architectural Features: Mix siding types to make certain areas stand out.

How We Help You Design Your Dream Exterior

When you work with us, you don’t have to guess how different James Hardie siding options will look. After our initial consultation, where we take measurements and photos, we create a high-resolution design rendering of your home. Within 5 to 7 days, you’ll receive a digital representation showcasing different siding combinations.

Not sure which style or color works best? No problem. We offer multiple renderings—whether it’s three or fifteen—to fine-tune the design until you absolutely love it. We can continue adjusting until we reach the perfect design for your home.

Popular James Hardie Siding Combinations

1. Classic Horizontal Lap with Board and Batten Accents

One of the most cost-effective and stylish ways to mix James Hardie siding is by using horizontal lap siding for most of the home and board and batten for accent areas. This combination adds character without overwhelming the overall design.

  • Lap siding: 7-inch wide planks provide a clean, traditional look.
  • Board and batten: Adds vertical interest, often used on front-facing sections.
  • Where to use it: The main body of the home gets lap siding, while board and batten accents appear in gables, entryways, or bump-outs.

2. Shake Siding for Added Texture

For a richer, more detailed look, James Hardie shake siding can be used in certain sections of the home. However, it is important to note that shingle and shake siding cost more per foot than other Hardie options.

  • Gables and dormers: Adds depth and visual interest.
  • Front-facing walls: Enhances curb appeal without covering the entire home.
  • Contrasting or complementary colors: You can match shake siding to your lap siding or choose a contrasting color for a bold look.

3. Monochromatic vs. Contrasting Color Schemes

Choosing between a monochromatic look and a contrasting color scheme depends on the statement you want to make.

  • Monochromatic designs use the same color across different siding styles for a cohesive, seamless look.
  • Contrasting colors highlight different textures and architectural features, making certain elements pop.

We can test both options in your design rendering so you can see which one fits your home best. Whether you prefer an all-one-color look or something bolder, our rendering process ensures you make the right choice before installation begins.

Budgeting for a Mix-and-Match Siding Project

While James Hardie shake and board and batten siding are among the most premium siding options, we help homeowners balance aesthetics with budget. The most cost-effective approach is using horizontal lap siding for most of the home while incorporating higher-end options in select areas.

At a minimum, homeowners often choose to add board and batten or shake siding in the front of the home, where it is most visible and adds the most curb appeal.

Work With Hawthorn Home Exteriors for Expert Siding Design

At Hawthorn Home Exteriors, we don’t just install siding—we help homeowners design their dream exterior. With our expert team and high-resolution renderings, you can be confident in your siding choices before installation begins.

In Summary

Mixing and matching James Hardie siding is a fantastic way to enhance the look of your home while staying within budget. Whether you prefer board and batten, shake siding, or classic lap siding, we can create a customized combination that suits your style.

If you want to see how different siding options will look on your home, contact us today. Let’s create a home exterior you’ll love!

Mark Moore

Mark Moore

Founder & CEO