James Hardie Smooth vs. Select Cedarmill: Which is Better?

Table of Contents

When it comes to enhancing the exterior of your home, choosing the right siding texture is paramount. One of the most common dilemmas homeowners face is deciding between smooth and select cedarmill options. Each texture offers its own set of advantages and visual appeal, making the decision a crucial one in achieving the desired look for your home. So, let’s explore the differences between James Hardie smooth vs. select cedarmill siding to help you navigate this important choice with confidence.

Exploring Hardie Textures

Hardie siding offers a diverse range of textures, catering to various design preferences and architectural styles. The smooth texture is characterized by its sleek and modern appearance, ideal for contemporary homes seeking a clean, minimalist look. On the other hand, the select cedarmill texture mimics the natural grain of cedar wood, offering a more rustic and traditional aesthetic.

Smooth Finish vs. Cedarmill Texture

When deciding between smooth and select cedarmill siding, it’s essential to consider the distinctive features and visual effects of each texture.

Smooth Finish:

The smooth texture delivers a polished and sophisticated appearance, with its clean lines and smooth surface. It offers a contemporary look that complements modern architectural styles, making it a popular choice among homeowners who prefer a sleek and minimalist aesthetic. The smooth finish creates a visually striking contrast against other exterior elements, such as brick or stone, adding depth and dimension to the overall design.

Select Cedarmill Texture:

In contrast, the select cedarmill texture exudes warmth and character, reminiscent of traditional wood siding. This texture features a subtle grain pattern that replicates the natural look and feel of cedar wood, providing a rustic charm to any home. The select cedarmill texture is particularly appealing for homeowners seeking to achieve a timeless and classic aesthetic, evoking a sense of authenticity and heritage.

Considerations When Choosing

Several factors should be taken into account when selecting the right siding texture for your home.

Design Preference:

Consider the overall style and architectural elements of your home. If you lean towards modern and contemporary designs, smooth siding may be the ideal choice. Conversely, if you prefer a more traditional or rustic look, select cedarmill texture could better suit your preferences.

Maintenance Requirements:

Both smooth and select cedarmill textures are known for their durability and low maintenance. However, it’s essential to consider any specific maintenance needs or preferences you may have when making your decision.

Environmental Considerations:

Take into account your local climate and environmental factors when choosing a siding texture. While both textures offer excellent durability and weather resistance, certain textures may be more suitable for specific climates or regions.

Making the Right Choice

Ultimately, the decision between smooth and select cedarmill siding comes down to your personal preferences and the desired aesthetic for your home. Whether you prefer the modern simplicity of smooth siding or the timeless charm of select cedarmill texture, James Hardie offers high-quality options to suit your needs.


In conclusion, the choice between James Hardie smooth vs. select cedarmill siding hinges on several factors, including design preferences, maintenance requirements, and environmental considerations. By understanding the unique features of each texture and evaluating how they align with your vision for your home, you can confidently select the siding texture that enhances both the beauty and durability of your home’s exterior.

If you’re ready to embark on this journey or need expert guidance, don’t hesitate to reach out to us. We’re here to assist you in making the perfect choice for your home.

Mark Moore

Mark Moore

Founder & CEO